The Hall of Fame Ballot

With the MLB Hall of Fame ballot released, I want to take a couple of days to pick out who should and should not be inducted.  Let’s start with contributors.  Contributors are voted on by a version of the Veterans’ Committee dedicated solely to electing candidates for something other than their play on the field.  They are split into two categories:  a 10-person ballot for managers and umpires and a 10-person ballot for executives and pioneers. Who should get in?

Start with executives and pioneers. The ballot includes 5 owners: Gene Autry (Angels), Ewing Kauffman (Royals), John Fetzer (Tigers), Jacob Ruppert (Yankees), and Sam Breadon (Cardinals); 3 general managers: Bob Howsam (builder of the Big Red Machine), John McHale (executive with the Tigers, Braves, and Expos), and Gabe Paul (builder of the Bronx Zoo Yankees); 1 NL president: Bill White; and Marvin Miller. As Verdun2 pointed out last week, Miller should be an easy pick. Few people in baseball history have changed the game like Miller. As head of the union, Miller introduced the world to free agency, killing the reserve clause that locked players into teams in perpetuity. Was Miller a nice man? Reports say the answer is no. Could the strike he backed in 1994 have killed baseball? Yes, it could have. The apt comparison, I think, is Judge Landis. The first baseball commissioner was essential in saving baseball from the problems surrounding the Black Sox scandal. At the same time, he single-handedly did everything possible to keep the game segregated. Jackie Robinson is possible, in part, because Landis was dead. Landis was a vile racist, and he was a deserved Hall of Famer for his contributions to the game. Miller is not nearly as nasty a human being, and regardless he deserves election.

The other executives are tricky. How do you decide which owners should be in and which not? I don’t know. I would probably vote for Ruppert as the man who transformed the Yankees into the franchise of Ruth and Gehrig. I would consider Howsam, as builder of the Big Red Machine and GM of the Cardinals for 1 World Series win and another appearance in the late 1960’s. The rest I would leave out.

The managers on the ballot are Danny Murtaugh, Billy Martin, Tom Kelly, Gene Mauch, Whitey Herzog, Davey Johnson, Steve O’Neill, and Charlie Grimm. Murtaugh (1960, 1971) and Kelly (1987, 1991) both won multiple World Series. Herzog (1982), Martin (1977), Johnson (1986) and O’Neill (1945) each won once. Grimm made 4 series (1932, 1935, 1938, 1945) as manager of the Cubs. Mauch never coached a pennant winner. Murtaugh and Kelly would be at the top of my list.

Hank O’Day and Doug Harvey are the ballots 2 umpires. Should they go in? I don’t know. Why not?

What do you think should happen to the contributors when the Veterans’ Committee votes on December 6th?

Explore posts in the same categories: Baseball

Tags: , , , , ,

You can comment below, or link to this permanent URL from your own site.

4 Comments on “The Hall of Fame Ballot”

  1. Millsy Says:

    I’m actually curious what the standards are for voting an umpire into the Hall of Fame. Does the HOF website actually have guidelines for this? Obviously it’s not best calls as decided by Questec, so what other requirements would an umpire have to meet besides # of world series? I’m not saying they shouldn’t be in the HOF, but it doesn’t seem like any sort of criteria could be laid out. Any ideas?

    • sportsphd Says:

      Here are the umpires elected so far. Here are the official rules. The relevant considerations appear to be:

      Voting: The Committee shall consider all eligible candidates and voting shall be based upon the individual’s record, ability, integrity, sportsmanship, character and contribution to the game. Electors may vote for as few as zero (0) and as many as four (4) eligible candidates deemed worthy of election. Write-in votes are not permitted.

      How you do that for umpires I cannot begin to imagine.

      • Millsy Says:

        Yeah, it seems left pretty open. I know a few names, and I’m sure writers know more than I, but I can’t imagine they can make fully educated decisions on it. So goes the HOF in general.

  2. verdun2 Says:

    I have a feeling that longevity and number of times umping in playoffs/World Series get factored in by the voters.
    Without knowing for sure, I presume there is some sort of paperwork given to the voters with short baseball biographies of each candidate. Makes sense to do that, but can’t prove it happens.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: